Best Sweet Onion Salsa Recipe

I LOVE salsa.  But it has to be good, fresh salsa. I love sweet salsa but don’t love the mango or the peach kind.  I also don’t like it spicy. I used to love the Sweet Onion Salsa from Aldi until about a year ago when they stopped carrying the brand I liked and switched to another less yummy brand.  I am not a huge fan of canned salsa either.  I have tried every kind and it just doesn’t taste fresh enough for me.  I know…I know…picky picky picky!

best ever sweet onion salsa recipe

Then I fell in love with Garden Fresh Gourmet Sweet Onion Salsa.  I have even Instagrammed my love of GFGSOS until the price was raised to $4.59 for 16 ounces.  We go through a truckload of salsa in this house.  I figured out we would be spending $60 a month on this salsa at the rate our family devours it.

Garden Fresh Gourmet Salsasweet onion salsa

So I set out to try and recreate the salsa myself.  Now I will say it doesn’t taste like Garden Fresh Gourmet (mine is more cilantro-y) but after several trials and errors, this stuff, in my opinion, is just as good as any fresh salsa out there.  And it costs about $1.50 and 5 minutes. Win and win! Plus the entire 16 ounces is 160 calories or 5 calories per tablespoon so it is a great way to add flavor without packing on the calories.



1 can of diced tomatoes (undrained) or 1 1/2 cups of fresh tomatoes

1/3 bunch of cilantro (or about a handful)

1/4 of a sweet onion (or 1/2 cup diced)

1 tablespoon vinegar

1/2 tablespoon agave nectar, real maple syrup or sugar (or I use 1 teaspoon of Truvia for a no-sugar option)

1/2 juice of a lime or 1 1/2 tablespoons of lime juice

1 teaspoon of minced garlic or one clove

1/4 heaping teaspoon of cumin

1/4 teaspoon coarse salt

1 jalapeno slice

1.  Measure out all the ingredients except for the tomatoes directly into the food processor. Blend until everything is chopped up.

cilantro in salsa

fresh salsa recipe

sweet onion salsa homemade

sweet onion salsa recipe homemade

2.  Next I add the can of tomatoes and pulse about 5-6 times in order to cut them down a bit.  However if you don’t like chunky salsa blend away.

fresh sweet onion salsa

I like it slightly chunky so I pulse just a few times…

fresh salsa recipe

Then I just store it in an airtight plastic container in the fridge and it is gone in 2 days flat.

fresh sweet onion and cilantro salsa

It is so good and my whole family gobbles it right up.

recipe sweet onion salsa

Download Free Plans for a Double Sliding Barn Door!


Enter your email and the DIY Barn Door Plans will be sent to your inbox!

100% secure. Powered by ConvertKit


  1. Carrie Dore says:

    I’m so happy to find this recipe! I moved to California a year ago and miss Garden Fresh Gourmet Salsa. I can’t tell you how many salsas I’ve tried here but haven’t found one that said YUM.


  1. […]  Best Sweet Onion Salsa from Infarrantly Creative […]

  2. […] The Best Sweet Onion Salsa from Infarrantly Creative […]

  3. […] Sweet Onion Salsa: RealSweet sweet onions are the only option for this classic crowd favorite. This recipe for homemade salsa is one you might want to keep to yourself! […]

Speak Your Mind